Stop Replacing Fundraisers. Start Keeping Them.

Stop Replacing Fundraisers. Start Keeping Them.

In my last edition, I wrote about fundraisers who get caught chasing money: the hamster wheel of activity that looks productive, feels empty, and often fails to deliver the desired results. This week I want to tell the other half of that story.

Whether a good fundraiser stays depends far more on leadership than most organizations admit.

Too many organizations start talking seriously about retention only after a fundraiser has given notice. By the time of the exit interview, the decision is made, and the chance to change the outcome is gone. Retention is earned long before anyone announces they’re leaving. It’s built in the everyday choices leaders make about goals, attention, and what the organization chooses to value.

It starts with the goal. Too often the philanthropic revenue line is worked backward from expenses: this is what we need to spend, so this is what development must raise. The number then lands on the fundraiser’s desk, with no one asking whether it’s achievable or what it would take to get there. A goal no one believes in ends in one of two ways: burnout or a pipeline built on hope rather than substance. Neither one serves the mission. The development team should help shape the goal, not just receive it. And before any number is final, leaders should ask what it will require, not only what it promises.

Next, pay attention to the work that never shows up in a gift total. The visit that built trust with a long-time donor. The introduction that reopened a door that had been shut for years. The thank-you call that kept a supporter close through a hard year. If leadership meetings and dashboards report only dollars raised, the fundraiser learns that dollars are all that matter, and the relationship work quietly stops. Track relationship progress next to revenue, and you’ll see behavior change.

Finally, leaders have to carry their own share. An executive director or CEO is the organization’s chief relationship officer whether the title says so or not. That means making visits, sitting beside the development team when the ask is made, and getting the board ready to open the doors only board members can open. When leaders share the relationships, the fundraiser isn’t holding them all alone. When they don’t, one person ends up carrying the mission’s entire financial future, and eventually that weight wins.

Three things leadership can do to strengthen a culture of philanthropy:

Bring development into the budget early. Your chief development officer should help build the revenue projections, not just inherit them.Make the calls yourself. Each member of the senior team makes two thank-you calls to donors, with no ask attached.Change what you measure. Add one line to every leadership report: relationships advanced, not just dollars received.

A culture of philanthropy is not a slogan on the wall. It shows in how leadership behaves when the numbers are soft and the goal is hard. It shows when nobody is watching, except the fundraiser, deciding whether to stay… or leave.

This article first appeared in The Yes Advantage Insider, the Getting to the Yes newsletter on LinkedIn.