Letters We Never Send: When Good Fundraisers Leave
Every year, nonprofits across the country lose talented, mission-driven fundraisers—not because they stopped caring, but because they stopped feeling cared for. The cost is staggering: recruitment, onboarding, lost donor momentum, and a cycle that keeps repeating itself.
What if your fundraiser could tell you the truth on their way out the door?
This is the first in a series of open letters written from the perspective of fundraisers, board members, and nonprofit leaders. Each one is a mirror held up to a moment we don’t talk about enough in our sector. These letters are fictional, but they are not made up. They are built from real conversations, real patterns, and real pain points I encounter every day in my work with nonprofits.
This one is for every CEO or Executive Director who lost a good fundraiser and still isn’t sure why.
Dear Executive Director,
I want you to know that I’m not leaving angry.
I’m leaving heartbroken.
I came to your organization because I believed in the mission with everything I had. I told your story to donors at dinner tables, in coffee shops, and in parking lots after site visits. I wasn’t reciting talking points. I meant every word. And I was good at this work, not because I could close a gift quickly, but because I could build something real with the people who cared about what you were doing.
That takes time. I know you knew that, at least in theory.
But somewhere between my first performance review and the third board meeting where someone asked why the major gifts pipeline wasn’t “producing yet,” I felt the ground shift beneath me. The patience you promised in my interview got shorter with every quarter. The realistic timelines we talked about became targets I couldn’t hit, not because I wasn’t working, but because relationships don’t run on fiscal years.
Here’s what I needed you to understand: I was planting. The harvest was coming. Donors were warming. Conversations were deepening. The kind of trust that becomes a transformational gift doesn’t happen in 12 months. It happens in twenty-four or thirty-six. I was right on schedule. Just not on yours.
And when the board started asking hard questions about my performance, I needed you to have my back. I needed you to stand in that room and say, “This is how major gift fundraising works, and we are going to trust the process.” Instead, I felt the silence. And in that silence, I got the message.
I want to be clear about something. I’m not leaving because I gave up on your donors or your mission. The donors will still give, maybe after a slower start with someone new, but they believe in what you’re building. What I couldn’t sustain was feeling invisible in my own organization.
I found a place that has committed to realistic timelines. A place where leadership understands that in year one you build, in year two you cultivate, and in year three you harvest. A place where my CEO will walk into a board meeting and educate the board about what fundraising actually requires, and defend that process even when it’s uncomfortable.
You invested in my professional development, and I’m grateful. But training me for conferences and credentials while starving me of patience, realistic expectations, and your public support?
You trained me for my next employer.
I hope the next person you hire receives a different experience. Not because I want you to struggle, but because your mission deserves a fundraiser who can stay long enough to see it fully funded.
With genuine love for what you’re trying to build,
Your Fundraiser
What’s Coming Next in This Series
This is just the first letter.
Coming up: a letter from a new fundraiser to their board, sharing what they wish board members understood about opening doors, making introductions, and what it actually means to be a fundraising partner. And later, a letter from a board member who finally got it, and what changed their mind. And several more.
If this letter made you feel something, share it. Forward it to a CEO who needs to read it. Hand it to a board chair. Use it to start a long-overdue conversation in your organization.
And, of course, sign up to receive The Yes Advantage Insider newsletter, delivered to your inbox weekly!